Crisis On Earth X Part 1 Supergirl S3 Ep8 Discussion

Wwooowhooo! Confirmed: Barry asks Kara to sing at the wedding. And, according to the article writer, it's amazing!!

TvGuide Article

Well the showrunners are looking to given Melissa a second chance at showing off her vocals. Consider what happened in the Flash crossover a slight off-step. Then again as a trapped Kara in the world of Music Meister, I think she had to do it that way.

At something more capable like the West Allen wedding, and since Barry and Kara are best (Super) friends) it seems to make sense.

My only speculation is...what song does she sing? Is it something operatic to show off her soprano chops, or perhaps the song Barry sang to Iris at the end of that show Running Home to You?

Oooo... That would be a good choice, especially with a more orchestral background? I'm even more excited since the article said we won't be expecting how. awesome it really is. Makes me think her singing is actually highlighted for a bit, and not just softly playing in the background.

I hope after Kara sings or before we get a brief scene of Barry explaining to Oliver how they got trapped in a musical, with Ollie being like 'glad I wasn’t there'. Really excited to hear Melissa sing again though, she has a beautiful voice!

Alright me mates, the goods is near, the good is near

Get set, get pumped, get hyped

Alright me mates, the goods is near, the good is near

Get set, get pumped, get hyped

I might very well be more excited for the crossover than Season 3 Ep 1. I mean, at this point in the game, we KNOW Season 3 is turning out possibly the best ever. AND...we even get MelB singing. AND we get 4 hours!

Oh AAANNNDDD....I just bought a new $1500 55" OLED tv. Sooooo....there's that, too.

I might very well be more excited for the crossover than Season 3 Ep 1. I mean, at this point in the game, we KNOW Season 3 is turning out possibly the best ever. AND...we even get MelB singing. AND we get 4 hours!

Oh AAANNNDDD....I just bought a new $1500 55" OLED tv. Sooooo....there's that, too.

Congratulations on the new TV.

I don't have to add much here, but i really like Overgirls costume. Well OK the SS is a bit to much, one S rune would have been enough, but the overall design is great.

Looks much like Overmans.

I might very well be more excited for the crossover than Season 3 Ep 1. I mean, at this point in the game, we KNOW Season 3 is turning out possibly the best ever. AND...we even get MelB singing. AND we get 4 hours!

Oh AAANNNDDD....I just bought a new $1500 55" OLED tv. Sooooo....there's that, too.

Congratulations on the new TV.

Thanks, Brier. Decided it's best to spend more to get what I want and keep it awhile than chasing new technology. Almost got the 65". But decided in the end it would probably overwhelm the room. Plus, not sure $800 more was worth a few more inches. But, man oh man the crossover is gonna look BRILLIANT!

I'm shutting myself out of social media 8pm EST! Probably hide under a rock for the next few hours, too...

Man the event feels like a big game will go on TV,...

I'm shutting myself out of social media 8pm EST! Probably hide under a rock for the next few hours, too...

Man the event feels like a big game will go on TV,...

Same, Triggy. Same. As soon as Eric hits twitter, I'm shuttin down social media till I'm through the two hours. I'll be an hour behind him and the east coasters.

I'm shutting myself out of social media 8pm EST! Probably hide under a rock for the next few hours, too...

Man the event feels like a big game will go on TV,...

Same, Triggy. Same. As soon as Eric hits twitter, I'm shuttin down social media till I'm through the two hours. I'll be an hour behind him and the east coasters.

I’ll be right behind you all waiting for 8 Pacific Time. I am going to stay so far away from Twitter....

The Supergirl vs. Overgirl fight will feel like it's taking place right in the room. You're not going to miss much with that screen Congrats!

I might very well be more excited for the crossover than Season 3 Ep 1. I mean, at this point in the game, we KNOW Season 3 is turning out possibly the best ever. AND...we even get MelB singing. AND we get 4 hours!

Oh AAANNNDDD....I just bought a new $1500 55" OLED tv. Sooooo....there's that, too.

Congratulations on the new TV.

Thanks, Brier. Decided it's best to spend more to get what I want and keep it awhile than chasing new technology. Almost got the 65". But decided in the end it would probably overwhelm the room. Plus, not sure $800 more was worth a few more inches. But, man oh man the crossover is gonna look BRILLIANT!

I'm worse off, because even though my time zone is Mountain Time, I get the West Coast feed from KSTW Seattle. So that's 1 more hour of wait.

I'm in Canada - GlobalTV placed Supergirl (staring Season 2) on their co-owned cable channel Showcase, which will show Supergirl at 8pm MST, tonight. CTV Two (national TV) will show Arrow at 9pm MST. Anyone who have not signed up for Showcase will miss out on the Supergirl part of the Crossover.

8 minutes to go for the East Coast! Enjoy!!!!!

Same, Triggy. Same. As soon as Eric hits twitter, I'm shuttin down social media till I'm through the two hours. I'll be an hour behind him and the east coasters.

I’ll be right behind you all waiting for 8 Pacific Time. I am going to stay so far away from Twitter....

Alright it appears the crossover has begun for you Americans. Don't tell me anything lol

The Supergirl vs. Overgirl fight will feel like it's taking place right in the room. You're not going to miss much with that screen Congrats!

Oh man, Sully.... Overgirl on my 55" was spectacular. I could see every tiny detail of the fabric. lol No joke.

But my heck, people!!!.... Took me twice as long to watch tonight because I found myself constantly rewinding parts just to rewatch some of their facials (especially Kara and Overgirl, and Alex's... Bah ha ha), rewatch Kara sing (like 5-6 times), and whatnot. So far...lots and lots of awesomeness. 137.734574 times more brilliant and entertaining than last year!!


Overgirl feels COMPLETELY different than Red Kryptonite Kara. MAJOR kudos to Melissa for that. RK Kara, afterall, WAS still Kara with Kara's memories. Overgirl is a completely different person. Well done, MelB. At first, I was worried Overgirl was going to feel a bit... "cheesy." A few lines by Melissa...the part about on HER earth, her pod was lucky enough to crash in the motherland...was delivered in a cheesy sounding cadence in Melissa's delivery (hope that makes sense). But, her interaction in the warehouse between Alex and Kara was much better

I've also been impressed with Stephen Amell's performance as the SS Arrow.

ONLY dissapointment, thus far... wanting a one-on-one with Alex and Overgirl. But, how Melissa delivered "Such, LOYALTY! MY sister tried to KILL me"...was hilarious.

Oh, and Sanver fans needn't worry. Alex and Sarah totally don't gel. In fact, Sarah seems more irritated with Alex, if anything. If Maggie didn't want kids, I REALLY don't see Sarah wanting to play mom.

Oh and P.S... Kiwi... I immediately noted... Blake's score was on... POINT tonight, especially the choral part towards the first SS scene.

P.S.S... How awesome was Guardian's suit? Loved the subtle changes.

Kara really likes to beat herself up when she's down.

Cringy pun delivered, mission complete.

The Supergirl vs. Overgirl fight will feel like it's taking place right in the room. You're not going to miss much with that screen Congrats!

Oh man, Sully.... Overgirl on my 55" was spectacular. I could see every tiny detail of the fabric. lol No joke.

But my heck, people!!!.... Took me twice as long to watch tonight because I found myself constantly rewinding parts just to rewatch some of their facials (especially Kara and Overgirl, and Alex's... Bah ha ha), rewatch Kara sing (like 5-6 times), and whatnot. So far...lots and lots of awesomeness. 137.734574 times more brilliant and entertaining than last year!!


Overgirl feels COMPLETELY different than Red Kryptonite Kara. MAJOR kudos to Melissa for that. RK Kara, afterall, WAS still Kara with Kara's memories. Overgirl is a completely different person. Well done, MelB. At first, I was worried Overgirl was going to feel a bit... "cheesy." A few lines by Melissa...the part about on HER earth, her pod was lucky enough to crash in the motherland...was delivered in a cheesy sounding cadence in Melissa's delivery (hope that makes sense). But, her interaction in the warehouse between Alex and Kara was much better

I've also been impressed with Stephen Amell's performance as the SS Arrow.

ONLY dissapointment, thus far... wanting a one-on-one with Alex and Overgirl. But, how Melissa delivered "Such, LOYALTY! MY sister tried to KILL me"...was hilarious.

Oh, and Sanver fans needn't worry. Alex and Sarah totally don't gel. In fact, Sarah seems more irritated with Alex, if anything. If Maggie didn't want kids, I REALLY don't see Sarah wanting to play mom.

Thoughts on evil SuperArrow?

Also Sara is not a 'relationship' sort of woman, at least not played that way on LOT, she's had lots of one night stands on that show so its actually in character for her to sleep with Alex.

Melissa is so good as Overgirl! And making an evil Oliver-Kara power couple is one of the best ideas I've seen in a long time - it's makes their motive to go in to Earth-1 believable (Overgirl dying if no new heart is obtained).

Best crossover ever! (so far)

I'm liking SuperArrow because I'm really enjoying seeing the mixing of different characters. Again, I'm REALLY wanting an Alex/Overgirl conversation....so Overgirl can see what she missed out on!

Overall, I think it was a good start to the crossover. I loved the sister scene on the couch. Wow, I forgot how much I missed those . Glad to see them back in some form.

Parts that stood out to me that I enjoyed (besides sister scene):

Opening scene with the three superhero's doing their thing.
Kara singing at the wedding
Supergirl, Flash and Arrow interaction. A lot of good lines thrown out between the three characters.
Action scenes at the church and in the warehouse.
Supergirl - Overgirl fight and interaction
The story between Victor Garber's character and the other half of his superhero persona

I wasn't that keen on the romantic angst in the episodes. It seemed a bit more heavy in the first hour but, still noticeable in the second episode. They definitely need to fill the episodes with something besides just action but, I thought they could have found something else. It made it appear as though all the shows have a fairly shallow pool of plots: superhero fighting villain or romance. My guess is that there won't be nearly as much in tonight's episodes so, I probably will like it even more.

Dialogue was very good in places and a bit cliched in others.

Loved the Supergirl clap!

One of my favorite lines by Alex, talking to Kara: Break-up weight and her resentment of Kara being incapable of putting on weight. Of all Supergirl's powers, I want THAT super power!