MEMBERS
Top Scene in Supergirl So Far

Ok, here we go. We've spent a good amount of time trying to discover which episode of Supergirl was the best so far! After three weeks of really hammering the vote, 'Falling' took the cake. It was a fun excercise and really got fans talking about what they like about Supergirl. That gave way to the idea that there are some scenes that really make episodes stand out. So, we asked you to nominate your favorite scenes! WOW you guys did great! There were a lot to choose from! In order to keep it all together, we've divided the scenes into four categories. Heroics, Action (fighting), Drama, and Comedy. Here are the rules:


You will get five votes per category. On Sunday, we will take the top five scenes from each category and put them up against each other much like we did with favorite episode! Don't forget you can vote for 5 each category!

Voting is for members only, you can be a member for free, sign up here. The "Vote Button" will appear when you are logged in:

Voting is closed, See latest article!

Don't forget to persuade your fellow fans in the comments below and in the forum! Keep the lights on and visit the support page!

Eric Johnston
Author: Eric JohnstonWebsite: https://supergirl.tvEmail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Executive Editor/Owner
About the Author
Eric is the primary author for Supergirl.tv. He has been covering the Supergirl show since 2014, but been a fan for decades. "Hope, Help, and Compassion for All, El May Arah!"

Comments   

#19 RE: Top Scene in Supergirl So FarFedguy 2019-06-28 18:10
@muckle9999
It's because there's a strong bias towards any scene involving Alex. Many cite sister moments as one of the strongest moments of the show, and indeed it's meant to be, but the characterisation of Alex has in my view progressively declined since Season 2, and therefore so does the value of those sister moments.
+1 #18 RE: Top Scene in Supergirl So Farmuckle9999 2019-06-27 12:45
Quoting Kiwi:
Quoting muckle9999:
I'm amazed that the scene with the pillow hitting Alex in the face is leading the way in comedy.


I found it to be a funny scene (which I'm considering giving my comedy scene vote to in the Top 20 round) helped by Melissa's laugh, goes like this - Alex (talking about Cat Grant) "....... Supergirl, I mean. Her assistant, no, she couldn't give a rip about" which prompts Kara to throw a cushion and hit Alex "right in the face" which Kara has a good laugh about. Just wonderful acting by Melissa and Chyler :-) .

There was a funny line earlier in that episode when Cat Grant describes one of Supergirl's Superpowers as "the freezy breath thing" :lol: .


Yes I agree that the pillow scene and the freezy breath thing line are HaHa funny.
But the entire alien bar scene where Monty get's Kara drunk and Alex seeing her in that happy drunken state is called Hilarious.
#17 RE: Top Scene in Supergirl So FarKelly 2019-06-27 09:32
I'm fine with whatever scenes win, its just a lot of fun voting on this stuff.....I just thought it was funny that the winning scene didn't really have any acting from the main character in it. Chyler, indeed, did very well in the scene. But, in the game of debate? I think that the scene in "Falling" far outshines any other dramatic scenes. To me, if we are looking at strong scenes from Chyler, the scene in "Solitude" where she confesses is the strongest for her.....AND YES Eric, DEFINITELY the "take the head off the AI" scene was phenomenal.....totally deserving.
+3 #16 RE: Top Scene in Supergirl So Farmuckle9999 2019-06-26 09:37
I salute the administrator for the time and effort with providing us with this fun exercise . I must say after looking at the results so far that I'm way out of step and touch with the rest of you guys. I'm amazed that the scene with the pillow hitting Alex in the face is leading the way in comedy.
#15 RE: Top Scene in Supergirl So FarLibertyPrime 2019-06-26 08:22
Quoting Katco:
Is the scene from Exodus (Season 2) where Supergirl stops the spaceship from going into space here? No one does "hand on glass" like Alex.

Under Heroics-- "Kara Pushes Spaceship Out Of Ascension" S2: EP 15
+1 #14 Best Scene So FarKatco 2019-06-26 07:47
Is the scene from Exodus (Season 2) where Supergirl stops the spaceship from going into space here? No one does "hand on glass" like Alex.
+2 #13 RE: Top Scene in Supergirl So FarKiwi 2019-06-26 03:49
Quoting LibertyPrime:
Many fine scenes from which to choose. I still found it difficult to say which is the best in any category, except maybe Saving the Plane in the pilot. But I distributed my votes as well as I could.


I found this round OK for deciding on which scenes to vote for, it's the next one that's going to be hard, of the 20 that are likely to go through I could give a vote to 13 of them, narrowing that down to 5 I'll have to think about carefully. I'm leaning toward 3 Heroics (which is my main thing with the show), 1 Comedy and 1 Drama scene.

It would be nice if the Saving the Plane scene from the Pilot was the top scene when voting ends Sunday week. I'm definitely hoping that at least one of the Supergirl being heroic scenes is the top one as IMHO that's the best thing about the show (Supergirl being Superheroic and saving lives). It would be nicer than say a scene like Supergirl vs Reign (which is a contender for top spot) where it was Supergirl being beaten to near death.

Always give me Supergirl being a heroine over a big fight any day of the week.
+2 #12 RE: Top Scene in Supergirl So FarSSAV 2019-06-25 21:37
Quoting Kelly:
How is a dramatic scene in Supergirl winning and the main character is out cold....lol SMH


Also, because it is about Kara as much as about Alex really. The episode has been building up from Kara's loss and then at that moment it switched to Alex's. It was shocking for Alex to see Kara down and remember; and shocking for us to have her down (I wasn't expecting that). To have her nearly at the end and then be brought back through something fairy tale like has a charm. It was an excellent scene at least in conception.

It doesn't just stress on Kara's importance to Alex but more subtly on Alex's importance to Kara.

And as the admin said, what the show has been showing about the sisters through four seasons. Without that background, the drama would have been lost.

Kara was the centrepiece, the trigger and the catalyst.
+2 #11 RE: Top Scene in Supergirl So FarSupergirl.tv Admin 2019-06-25 20:56
Quoting Kelly:
How is a dramatic scene in Supergirl winning and the main character is out cold....lol SMH

A fair question, but ... I think that a scene that showcases Alex’s reaction to Kara’s potential death has a weight with it in season 4 that other scenes don’t. We, at this point, have the context of all the other great scenes between the sisters and this is the height of that relationship ... so far. That is why there is a gravity there. That said, most of not all my votes were Melissa/Sister scenes. Honorary mention to when Kara walked in on Alura’s Hologram and yelled at her for leaving her and heat visioning her image! W O W
#10 RE: Top Scene in Supergirl So FarKelly 2019-06-25 20:40
How is a dramatic scene in Supergirl winning and the main character is out cold....lol SMH


Register as a user to comment on this article. Register