MEMBERS
Of Two Mind Recap

There are many reveals still left to be explored this season of Supergirl but one major reveal happened tonight! The identity of Pestilence was discovered and she is bringing quite a wallop! Those of you that are more active members of our site might have already known or guessed who Pestilence was but nonetheless, the irony of her identity was not lost on us. Furthermore, Alex was faced with a very tough realization and Winn/James and Lena/Sam stole the show. What specifically stood out to us? Just check out our recap below:

  1. Saturn Girl vs Supergirl: No killing Saturn Girl! While we can understand that Saturn Girl wants to do something that guarantees a safe outcome for the millions of lives in the 31st century, killing is a non-starter for Supergirl. It's kind of hero 101 and we think this will come back again and again for the heroes.
  2. Reign and Sam Talk: This was very fascinating to us. We've been seeing the dark forest that Sam goes to when Reign is in control but we just felt it was like a metaphor for a dark place in her mind. That said, if what Lena says is correct, then she is actually going to a new dimension! That reminds us of the pocket dimension that Flash's "Thinker" operates out of.
  3. The Needs of the Many ... : It's a common question that is examined in comics and the larger nerd culture. Star Trek gave Spock the famous line, "The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, or the one". However, when it comes to Superman and Supergirl, the right thing is ALWAYS upheld. Logically, like Spock, Imra's position is very understandable, however, if the Girl of Steel has taught us anything, it's that there is always a better way.
  4. James and Winn: We remember asking Ali Adler in season 1 what it was like to show positive female relationships outside of romantic love. She was a little taken-a-back but loved the question. You can see it in our interview section on the videos page. We followed up with if they were going to explore positive male relationships as well. After seeing the scene between Winn and James, we have no doubt that Supergirl the show can show amazing relationships of any type.
  5. Pestilence Joins Purity: Just when things started to go one way, Purity shows up and saves her sister from Saturn Girl, Supergirl and Mon-El. Now with Reign as the last piece of the trinity, it's only a matter of time until the three get together and are powered up by each other. Very difficult times are ahead for team Supergirl.
  6. Trinity: Well that didn't take long! In a matter of moments after the battle with Pestilence and Purity, the three were united and Supergirl and team were held off via some new powers of the combined Worldkillers! If that wasn't enough, you had Reign throw Supergirl's phrase back in her face with "El May Arah"! EPIC!

All in all, this episode was amazing and really teed up some big things coming soon. The team knows Sam is Reign, the trinity have been found and Lena's work behind Supergirl's back might have some consequences for Kara and Lena!

Let us know what you thought of the episode in the comments below and the forum! Keep us advertisement free and visit the support page too!

Eric Johnston
Author: Eric JohnstonWebsite: https://supergirl.tvEmail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Executive Editor/Owner
About the Author
Eric is the primary author for Supergirl.tv. He has been covering the Supergirl show since 2014, but been a fan for decades. "Hope, Help, and Compassion for All, El May Arah!"

Comments

+1 #38 RE: Of Two Minds RecapSSAV 2018-05-02 21:48
Quoting DraftingDrafter:

To be fair, Lena doesn't know that Supergirl is Kara. So yes, Kara (and Alex) wouldn't treat Sam like that but that wasn't Lena's thinking. She equates both Alex and Supergirl as members of a government organization that specializes in handling alien threats, I can understand her hesitation and reluctance to call them.


I see your point. When I mentioned Kara, I meant Supergirl in this case. Supergirl has been a proven friend of aliens and has been shown to give people second chances's. Whether she has killed in battle or not, there has been nothing to suggest she would treat people horribly. Quite the opposite in fact.

And Lena knows Alex and knows Kara is her sister. She could have trusted Kara to lead Alex towards the right path even if she is not sure about Alex herself. And... I was also surprised that Lena didn't feel concerned for Kara when she found out that Alex was sick. Basically, in my opinion, that James check in was not needed at all. It doesn't do justice to any of the characters and didn't serve any purpose.

I am not a Lena hater by the way (and I think Katie Mcgrath has been doing a very good job these past few episodes). But, I think instead of the Morgan Edge episodes, they could have done a better job of building Lena up as the grey character everyone assumes she is... so that if she remains SG's friend or not would have been actually nail-biting.
+3 #37 RE: Of Two Minds RecapThalolli 2018-05-02 04:49
I liked a lot of Supergirl's plot with Kandor and Argo in the comics. It's usually always very emotional. I like those plots more with her than with Superman because she actually remembers those places and of course it's always very tragic when she has to see those places in ruins or learns that the people there are very flawed too or when she has to lose them all over again. I really hope that the show will do justice to that plot if they decide to tackle it.
+2 #36 RE: Of Two Minds RecapDraftingDrafter 2018-05-02 00:14
I thought this was a great episode; it was a huge episode (imo) in terms of pushing our main plots forward.

We finally have the Reign/Sam reveal, we have the 3rd world killer, we have full involvement of the Legion, and we have Lena being brought into the fold.

The episodes are getting better and better each week, I'm excited to see where next week's episode takes us.
+2 #35 RE: Of Two Minds RecapDraftingDrafter 2018-05-02 00:11
Quoting Littlegoldfish666:
The Lena/Sam scenes were hood as always. Those two really sell it onscreen. I really hope Lena can find a way to save Sam and destroy Reign. The Sam/Reign talks were intriguing and slightly creepy.

I'm so glad Kara and Imra are on the way to maybe becomng friends and they've come to an understanding

As for Lena's secret, well Kara/Supergirl can't take the moral high ground here as she's been keeping secrets since day one about everything while up to this point Lena has been honest with Kara. On this show it's like "oh I can keep screts and lie to you but you aren't allowed to do the same because i'll get my knickers in a twist if you do" But yeah Lena done the right thing here with the information she had at the time. She had no idea about the others and she's the only chance Sam had because what Lena said about them locking her away and using her as a lad rat is probably accurate

Agreed on all fronts.

Those Lena and Sam scenes are always so emotionally charged, they're great.

Kara and Imra coming to an understanding via heartfelt connection was a joy to see.

Secrets. Those are very tricky when it comes to superhero shows. There's always two sides to the story when it comes to secrets and I can see why certain characters keep certain secrets.
+1 #34 RE: Of Two Minds RecapDraftingDrafter 2018-05-02 00:07
Quoting SSAV:
Quoting Littlegoldfish666:

As for Lena's secret, well Kara/Supergirl can't take the moral high ground here as she's been keeping secrets since day one about everything while up to this point Lena has been honest with Kara. On this show it's like "oh I can keep screts and lie to you but you aren't allowed to do the same because i'll get my knickers in a twist if you do" But yeah Lena done the right thing here with the information she had at the time. She had no idea about the others and she's the only chance Sam had because what Lena said about them locking her away and using her as a lad rat is probably accurate


Considering that her keeping the secret directly led to the other two worldkillers breaking Sam away, Kara definitely has the moral highground. And, not just that, Lena said that she was close to breakthrough on pestilence while she was not (did she even know what she was talking about then). And, no... Kara or Alex either would have never used Sam as a lab rat. Kara's behaviour so far is against it. And what Lena was doing with her was also treating her as lab rat. Painfully so.

To be fair, Lena doesn't know that Supergirl is Kara. So yes, Kara (and Alex) wouldn't treat Sam like that but that wasn't Lena's thinking. She equates both Alex and Supergirl as members of a government organization that specializes in handling alien threats, I can understand her hesitation and reluctance to call them.
+1 #33 RE: Of Two Minds RecapSSAV 2018-05-01 21:49
I have been more or less indifferent to Lena since her story became repetitive. It is the Sam arc that gave her something to do. And, at least from this episode, I can see how she can go over to the dark side because of her hubris. I don't think it's Eugenics or genetics (aka Luthor blood). But rather, pride, which would be both nurture as well as nature... and her own personality.

Nobody is talking about how a lot of us feared Imra's worst fear would be losing Mon El to Kara and instead it turned out to be losing her sister all over again? I was so happy to see that. :-)

I agree with Brierrose that there were some editing issues with this episode.
+1 #32 RE: Of Two Minds RecapSSAV 2018-05-01 21:46
Quoting Littlegoldfish666:

As for Lena's secret, well Kara/Supergirl can't take the moral high ground here as she's been keeping secrets since day one about everything while up to this point Lena has been honest with Kara. On this show it's like "oh I can keep screts and lie to you but you aren't allowed to do the same because i'll get my knickers in a twist if you do" But yeah Lena done the right thing here with the information she had at the time. She had no idea about the others and she's the only chance Sam had because what Lena said about them locking her away and using her as a lad rat is probably accurate


Considering that her keeping the secret directly led to the other two worldkillers breaking Sam away, Kara definitely has the moral highground. And, not just that, Lena said that she was close to breakthrough on pestilence while she was not (did she even know what she was talking about then). And, no... Kara or Alex either would have never used Sam as a lab rat. Kara's behaviour so far is against it. And what Lena was doing with her was also treating her as lab rat. Painfully so.
+1 #31 RE: Of Two Minds Recapsuperbill 2018-05-01 18:23
I'm late to the party on this one, as I wasn't able to watch until today. It was another great episode with superior acting. Kudos to Odette who was brilliant. I also liked that Kara and Imra reached an understanding. What I am most impressed with is the careful way the writers have been building this story line throughout the season. Layer upon layer they have been developing the characters and the plot, intertwining peripheral characters into the fabric so they are a part of the main story and not just subplots. I think this is what sets this season apart from the first two. Really looking forward to how all this is going to play out!
+1 #30 RE: Of Two Minds RecapSully 2018-05-01 16:35
I thought that this episode was almost like a damn breaking. A great deal of information that had been kept back for the last few episodes was finally exposed, which was a good thing. However, the negative side was that it all released at once in this one episode, causing the episode to seem very rushed and cut up.

I liked the talk between Winn and James. The focus on James as a friend these last few episodes has really helped increase my appreciation for his character. It was nice seeing Alex doing her science thang and I also enjoyed Winn playing the gullible Brainy with the Freddy Kruger description.

Usually, I take Kara's side on how she handles things but, I agreed completely with Imra and Brainy's approach to how to deal with Pestilence. They're from the future and they know with 100% certainty that Kara's approach fails so, the decision to stop the perpetrator to save millions is the most rational. Mon-El taking Kara's side when he's from the future and knows of Kara's failure and has seen the same results makes absolutely no sense.

Lena's already starting to slide into that morally grey area. She lied to James about working on a cure to save millions when in fact, she wasn't and her inflated ego pushing her to go solo with Sam were two indicators of that true Luthor blood rising to the surface.
#29 RE: Of Two Minds RecapKelly 2018-05-01 13:35
Quoting SuperMatt:
Quoting muckle9999:
Quoting kdickerson87:
Sooooooo ummm...I'm gonna need the supergirl writers to allow J'onn use every power that he has to help Supergirl. They need to also allow the Legionnaires especially Mon-El to really maximize their capabilities for this next fight because it's about to get real. I know that we don't want to outshine the main character but even Flash and Black Lightning has powerful side kicks who are using all power that they have all the time. We have some sharp intelligent people on this show who can help, Alex, Winn, & Lena who are mentally capable to assist.

Nevertheless, this season is dope. It gets better and better. Tonight's episode was good but as great as last weeks. I'm glad Mon-El is taking up for Kara so I do hope that he ditch Imra and get back with Kara.


I'm hearing that Kara and Monty are going to be featured in back to back episodes. Something about going to Argo City for something and find Kara's mom who is stranded but alive.


Never liked the Kandor plot, honestly having a city full of Kryptonians still alive???


I loved that arc in the comics, but I'm really afraid that it is going to be a one or two and done kind of thing in the tv version....I would love to have that full arc, as well as Superwoman....not sure I'm going to get either. :sigh:


Register as a user to comment on this article. Register