facebook twitter reddit google+ you tube tumblr
MEMBERS

SEARCH

TWITTER

Favorite Guest Appearance Season 2

Time for our next contest! But before we jump into that, here are the results of the previous poll. Best supporting actor goes to Katie McGrath with 51.4% of the vote. The silver medal goes to Chris Wood with 26.48% of the vote and the bronze medal goes to Chyler Leigh with 15.37%. Now we want to know who was your favorite guest? These are characters that didn't appear in many episodes but brought something exciting to the show when they showed up. Voting is to the right (or below if you are on your phone)!

Let us know who you voted for and why in the comments below or the forum! Keep us going this summer and visit the support page.

Eric Johnston
Author: Eric JohnstonWebsite: https://supergirl.tvEmail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Executive Editor/Owner
About the Author
Eric is the primary author for Supergirl.tv. He has been covering the Supergirl show since 2014, but been a fan for decades. "Hope, Help, and Compassion for All, El May Arah!"

Comments   

#19 invitados en la seriedarksteel 2017-06-21 18:30
sigan invitando a linda carter y superman ya que es su primo y son un duo genial y maravillosos ya no pongan sus vidas amorosas por que son un lio y triste mejor historias del comic de supergirl y por este medio quiero felicitar a mellisa por que es una gran supergirl y hermosa mejor no pudieron escojer para interpretar a supergirl y su mama la primer supergirl deberian de sacar una historia de ella en una temporada ya que seria genial ver a las dos mejores supergirls que an existido para este personaje de dc comic

"Continue inviting cute carter and superman since it is their cousin and they are a great and wonderful duo no longer put their love lives because they are a mess and sad better comic stories of supergirl and by this means I want to congratulate mellisa because it is a Great supergirl and beautiful better could not choose to play supergirl and her mom the first supergirl should draw a story of her in a season as it would be great to see the two best supergirls who have existed for this comic dc character"
#18 The Queen of All MediaDraftingDrafter 2017-06-12 21:20
Without a doubt and zero hesitation, my pic for favorite guest appearance is the queen of all media herself, Cat Grant. Calista delivers such extraordinary performances as Cat.

I see a lot of votes for Superman/Tyler. I like this version of Supes okay. I grew up watching Smallville, so I find it hard to fully accept Tyler as Clark when for 10 seasons I watched Tom Welling portray him. (I still wish to this day that they would've picked Tom to reprise his role as Clark :sad: )

If Calista doesn't win this, I'll be glad if Tyler does.
#17 RE: Favorite Guest Appearance Season 2Stewart Tick 2017-06-12 20:31
"Superman - The man of steel is in the show and he doesn't steal the limelight away from SuperGirl. That takes a good actor since he is such a powerful character. His voice remains calm and he mentors Kara as well as learning from her. He doesn't come across as being conceited or smart mouth but instead plays his character with handsome charm and a sophistication worthy of the House of El. "

Yes, Tyler plays the Superman of the Silver Age comics very well. This is the Superman that I grew up with, so I've been very pleased with Tyler's performance.

https://flic.kr/p/CgcgAc
#16 RE: Favorite Guest Appearance Season 2Matt R 2017-06-12 15:51
Choosing between Cat and Superman was tough and as much as I love Superman I had to vote for Cat. Also, I’m glad that Katie won but just out of curiosity who did you guys (Eric & Kelsey) pick? You posted your picks of the last polls but this one.
#15 RE: Favorite Guest Appearance Season 2Jordan860 2017-06-12 14:14
Quoting RH321:
Quoting Kelly:
I also have to do a shout out to M'gann. I really enjoyed the dynamic she brought to the show and to Jonn. I was hoping for more time between her and Kara, but that just didn't happen....and that's ok. I would definitely put her in a close 2nd behind Cat.

I love Barry and Cisco as well, they just weren't much, last few seconds of an episode just didn't deem them my vote this time around. Hopefully we get to have a full episode within the crossover and more our our favorite SG peeps can interact with the other shows peeps. :)


I am also looking forward to the crossover. I wonder how many characters will come to our Earth. I loved Barry's appearance in Season 1 and can only assume that more characters will get to interact with whomever shows up on Earth-38 for the crossover. As for those going to the other Earth, I think the suited heroes/aliens will make the trip but it'll be nice if humans like Alex or Winn do too. I wonder what a conversation with Winn, Cisco and Felicity would be like,


I just hope Chyler gets to be in a crossover for once! Alex and Barry would get along like a house on fire.
#14 RE: Favorite Guest Appearance Season 2RH321 2017-06-12 14:03
Quoting Kelly:
I also have to do a shout out to M'gann. I really enjoyed the dynamic she brought to the show and to Jonn. I was hoping for more time between her and Kara, but that just didn't happen....and that's ok. I would definitely put her in a close 2nd behind Cat.

I love Barry and Cisco as well, they just weren't much, last few seconds of an episode just didn't deem them my vote this time around. Hopefully we get to have a full episode within the crossover and more our our favorite SG peeps can interact with the other shows peeps. :)


I am also looking forward to the crossover. I wonder how many characters will come to our Earth. I loved Barry's appearance in Season 1 and can only assume that more characters will get to interact with whomever shows up on Earth-38 for the crossover. As for those going to the other Earth, I think the suited heroes/aliens will make the trip but it'll be nice if humans like Alex or Winn do too. I wonder what a conversation with Winn, Cisco and Felicity would be like,
#13 RE: Favorite Guest Appearance Season 2Kelly 2017-06-12 13:19
I also have to do a shout out to M'gann. I really enjoyed the dynamic she brought to the show and to Jonn. I was hoping for more time between her and Kara, but that just didn't happen....and that's ok. I would definitely put her in a close 2nd behind Cat.

I love Barry and Cisco as well, they just weren't much, last few seconds of an episode just didn't deem them my vote this time around. Hopefully we get to have a full episode within the crossover and more our our favorite SG peeps can interact with the other shows peeps. :)
#12 RE: Favorite Guest Appearance Season 2superbill 2017-06-12 13:07
Gotta be Cat Grant. She brings sooooo much to the show.
#11 RE: Favorite Guest Appearance Season 2vantheman77 2017-06-12 12:57
Sorry had to go with Superman. Lot of hype surrounded his appearances.
#10 RE: Favorite Guest Appearance Season 2jacksc01 2017-06-12 12:30
Another hard question - so again I will go from my most favorite to favorite because I think these 4 were all great:

Cat Grant - is number one because besides being a strong female character, she also brings back a little bit of what is missing from season one. She is a mentor and friend to both Kara and SuperGirl.

Superman - The man of steel is in the show and he doesn't steal the limelight away from SuperGirl. That takes a good actor since he is such a powerful character. His voice remains calm and he mentors Kara as well as learning from her. He doesn't come across as being conceited or smart mouth but instead plays his character with handsome charm and a sophistication worthy of the House of El.

The Flash - IMO if he didn't already have a love interest and was from a different earth - he would have been the perfect love interest for SuperGirl - I would have loved to have seen these two be a couple - they are so adorable together. The Flash just has that perfect personality - you can't help but love him. What an endgame couple they would have made. However, as we know this is not possible.

Helen Slater - Again, a quiet character who deserves to be in more episodes. She brings a quiet motherlike maturity to the show.


Register as a user to comment on this article. Register