MEMBERS
City of Lost Children Inside Look

Does the Guardian inspire hope in people like Superman and Supergirl? That is the question James is asking going into tomorrow's new episode of Supergirl! In the inside look at City of Lost Children, it looks like James could be considering hanging up the Guardian helmet. We've always felt like we could understand James' motivations to become Guardian with friends like Kara and Clark. But if his goal is to add to the Hope, Help, and Compassion that Supergirl exudes to the world, Guardian may not be the vehicle to do that in. Check out what the producers had to say in the inside look below:

Let us know what you think in the comments below and in the forum! Keep us advertisement free and visit the support page too!

Eric Johnston
Author: Eric JohnstonWebsite: https://supergirl.tvEmail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Executive Editor/Owner
About the Author
Eric is the primary author for Supergirl.tv. He has been covering the Supergirl show since 2014, but been a fan for decades. "Hope, Help, and Compassion for All, El May Arah!"

Comments

#12 RE: City of Lost Children Inside LookRH321 2017-05-08 11:28
Quoting RobertAnthony:
Another reason this season has been a disappointment for me aside from the political undertones and going too soap opera-like is James as this lame Batman-like character. I hope by the end of the season Guradian is done away with. BUT...I did see on social media a BTS picture of a funeral with Superman attending it. I hope, HOPE that this does not mean James is the one who dies in either of the next two episodes. If it is, I would be sad at this because I wanted to give James a chance and I am ready to do so, but just not as Guardian. Besides, the show is called SUPERGIRL. Better writing, please student of Mark Guggenheim?


The BTS was from the now cancelled NBC show Powerless.
#11 RE: City of Lost Children Inside LookRobertAnthony 2017-05-08 10:28
Another reason this season has been a disappointment for me aside from the political undertones and going too soap opera-like is James as this lame Batman-like character. I hope by the end of the season Guradian is done away with. BUT...I did see on social media a BTS picture of a funeral with Superman attending it. I hope, HOPE that this does not mean James is the one who dies in either of the next two episodes. If it is, I would be sad at this because I wanted to give James a chance and I am ready to do so, but just not as Guardian. Besides, the show is called SUPERGIRL. Better writing, please student of Mark Guggenheim?

That said, I do sense a father/son relationship with James and the alien kid once the Guardian stuff lays low. I think though this is a James-centered show, it may not really be a throwaway because there is more on Rhea and Lena's plans and how Mon-El may have snapped and is going to do major harm to his vindictive mother, who killed his father.

And of course poor Lena is the tortured soul in this...I have begged time and again do NOT MAKE LENA GO HEEL!
#10 RE: City of Lost Children Inside LookChucky 2017-05-08 08:28
Tonights the Night!
#9 RE: City of Lost Children Inside LookThalolli 2017-05-07 21:11
I think Guardian is scary to people because of the mask/helmet. And to be honest, the mask, the voice, that is a lot more Batman (who intentionally uses fear against his enemies, "I am the night!") than Superman. In that episode where he wrongly gets framed for murder, he was still stringing people up, which was still pretty dark.

I don't know how they can resolve all that though without him taking off his helmet.
#8 RE: City of Lost Children Inside LookRH321 2017-05-07 19:33
Quoting vantheman77:
I hope this will be the end of James as Guardian as he has a lot on his plate with Catco.

I wonder if James is in the final two episodes of the season.


Saying he has a lot on his plate with CatCo makes sense in theory but we rarely get to see this aspect of his life.
#7 RE: City of Lost Children Inside Lookvantheman77 2017-05-07 18:30
I hope this will be the end of James as Guardian as he has a lot on his plate with Catco.

I wonder if James is in the final two episodes of the season.
#6 RE: City of Lost Children Inside LookRomulus 2017-05-07 18:14
Very nice. I hope the episode adds a little more depth to the Guardian character and that it clarifies a, to-date, unclear and ill-defined role for James. Let's hope the episode fits into the series and allows James / Guardian to find a meaningful reason for being in the series.
#5 RE: City of Lost Children Inside LookTriggy 2017-05-07 16:27
Okay maybe this episode will be a three-prong fork on the road for the Guardian character. 1) Nothing significant happens and it'll be status quo for him 2) He's seen the light of what damage he has done all along (let's juxtapose the Supergirl series here) and will throw off the helmet 3) like Jacksc01 said he'll submit to be under the leadership of the DEO. I'm open to the latter two.

Being under the DEO he can be an asset. To me what was unappealing with the Guardian was he is answerable to no one, and he's a distraction (both to all the characters and the show itself). It could have been more meaningful if the writers knew where they were going with the character and had planned for this episode early on if J'onn made it clear once in a while how opposed he was to James being in the way as Guardian. To me the writers didn't know what they were getting into by introducing Guardian. (I could be very wrong.)

We'll see how the rest of the series goes from here.
#4 RE: City of Lost Children Inside LookKelly 2017-05-07 15:28
Nice....finally James is learning what Kara has said since finding out that he was Guardian....he was a hero long before he became Guardian, and as James IMO, he is far more plausible than a wannabe, egotistical, cares more about his reputation than the people he is hurting who are trying to help him, (ie Winn). Hopefully this is the end to a pointless storyline and the beginning of us getting back to the sweet James of Season 1. A reboot on James is needed, hopefully this is the start, because it looks like a good one. :)
#3 RE: City of Lost Children Inside Lookjacksc01 2017-05-07 15:04
Wow - this looks like it will be a cool episode. This goes back to my thoughts that people fear Guardian because he tends to go off doing his own thing instead of working on cases with SuperGirl and the DEO. This could mean that James gives up being Guardian or it could be a leadway into Guardian becoming part of the DEO (a thought that would be cool because then the Superfriends would still be together). I think that if he goes out on cases with SuperGirl and the DEO, people will recognize him more in the same respect that they hold for SuperGirl. Should be interesting to see which way this turns out for James and the Guardian character. Either way, I hope James the character is here to stay since he is an original and helped SuperGirl become the hero she is today in National City.


Register as a user to comment on this article. Register