MEMBERS
Best Episode So Far: Prove It!

Surprise! There's a third round in our quest to find the best episode of Supergirl so far! While in round one, we restricted voting between seasons, now we are going to have an all-out free-for-all! We want to know, if the boundaries between seasons were removed, would the results for top 5 episodes be the same? To further add to the difficulty of this round, we are taking away two of your votes! You will only be able to vote for THREE EPISODES PER USER! We didn't want to make it a one vote and done because that seems a bit too difficult. Speaking for myself, there are a few episodes I love equally. Be sure to use your three votes wisely!

The question remains, will Falling continue to be our users absolute favorite episode? Will the other four continue to be in the top 5 or will the removal of seasonal boundaries push a few episodes aside? We will keep the poll running for one week and this time next week on Supergirl Sunday, we will have an absolute answer!

You must be logged in to see the vote and results button, some additional css classes were added so you might need to refresh your cache.

Best Episode of Supergirl: Prove It Poll

Let us know your thoughts and try and persuade your fellow users in the comments below and in the forum! Keep us alive and kicking this summer and visit the support page!

Eric Johnston
Author: Eric JohnstonWebsite: https://supergirl.tvEmail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Executive Editor/Owner
About the Author
Eric is the primary author for Supergirl.tv. He has been covering the Supergirl show since 2014, but been a fan for decades. "Hope, Help, and Compassion for All, El May Arah!"

Comments   

+4 #28 RE: Best Episode So Far: Prove It!evrafter 2019-06-14 16:49
Technically, the only way we can truly find out the #1 episode is to only give us one vote. Falling may currently have the most over-all votes, but we don't know how many of us put it as our actual first vote. For all we know, Falling was simply just more people's 3rd vote.

It WAS my first vote. Just sayin. Still love the poll. It's helped me narrow down which episodes I should rewatch--which I've been doing since summer vacation started... every night... before bed....because I can... Cuz I'm a teacher... and I earned a break... from teenagers... AND their parents...yay me. :o 8)
#27 RE: Best Episode So Far: Prove It!muckle9999 2019-06-13 12:45
Quoting Kiwi:
Admin, are the votes of Round 2 and 3 going to be combined or remain separate?. The only thing of interest left is the battle for 2nd place between FTGWHE and Midvale. Last I saw of the Round 2 poll Midvale was ahead by 1 vote, currently in this Round 3 poll FTGWHE is ahead by 2 votes.


Hold your horses Kiwi. :eek: It ain't over till it's over! It's my understanding that the administrator has another ace up her sleeve or it may be a joker. One more vote for the finale.
+2 #26 RE: Best Episode So Far: Prove It!Supergirl_peril 2019-06-11 15:13
Quoting muckle9999:
Quoting Supergirl_peril:
3. Pilot
2. Nevertheless She Persisted
1. Reign


Very nice selection. I watched Nevertheless She Persisted the other night and that episode is worthy of the top 3. I was all in with Kara and Monty and that season's finale is one of the best. You forget how good these past episodes are until you refresh them.



I picked those three because the pilot will always be one of my favorites. The show that introduced us to Melissa as Supergirl. What an amazing choice for the title role, she is everything the could have hoped for and much, much more. The movie in my opinion will be a let down, I almost feel bad for the actress that will try to compare to her. Honestly, will probably watch anyway, but can't imagine anyone playing this role better.

Nevertheless She Persisted to me was the best finale so far. So much action, and a great fight where the girl of steel proved herself under some dire circumstances. Very well done, I thought.

Reign has got to be number one for me, if nothing else for the shock value. I was pretty sure with all of the build up to Reign that Supergirl was going to take it on the chin in their first battle. Wow, though, who could have been prepared for that. The entire fight sequence she fought well, which I liked, but when Reign turned the battle in her favor, it was shocking how soundly she defeated Supergirl. Obviously we all knew she would be ok, and back for a rematch. The first fight was so intense, and so shocking. So well done and well acted, it was just amazing.

Just my thoughts. :)
#25 RE: Best Episode So Far: Prove It!muckle9999 2019-06-11 14:50
Quoting Supergirl_peril:
3. Pilot
2. Nevertheless She Persisted
1. Reign


Very nice selection. I watched Nevertheless She Persisted the other night and that episode is worthy of the top 3. I was all in with Kara and Monty and that season's finale is one of the best. You forget how good these past episodes are until you refresh them.
#24 Top 3Supergirl_peril 2019-06-10 20:47
3. Pilot
2. Nevertheless She Persisted
1. Reign
+2 #23 RE: Best Episode So Far: Prove It!Sully 2019-06-10 19:45
Well, the rational side of me feels guilty if my pedantic observation of the poll data caused more work for you, admins. :oops: . On the other hand, I'm also very curious to see how the numbers compare throughout the results - not just the top three or five. Plus, repeating of the poll will help strengthen any replicated results that may occur. However, as I said earlier, I do believe that the top episode result from your first poll would be considered valid.

And, in any case, this is a fun thing to participate in and see. I really don't see any issues with doing it again. It's not like we're overwhelmed with keeping up with news items or ongoing discussions. It keeps us occupied during this bit of a stretch we have before the next season begins. Thanks for doing this :-) .
+1 #22 RE: Best Episode So Far: Prove It!Kelly 2019-06-10 17:57
Quoting Supergirl.tv Admin:
Hey, so I have seen some confusion and some distaste for this current poll. I thought this would be fun with the change of rules and order but if this isn’t fun just let me know. I do have plans for when we have a final but I want to be respectful to our audience.


I was just confused because it didnt seem like we let the other poll follow through to its completion. I would have liked to have seen the top 5 go against each other...but hey I will vote in whatever, it's just silly fun in the end.
+1 #21 RE: Best Episode So Far: Prove It!muckle9999 2019-06-10 15:30
Quoting Kiwi:
Quoting Brierrose:
Quoting Kiwi:
After the best episode poll I would've probably done one for best (or favourite) season (plus 4 results are easier to read than 87 :-) ).
Please no poll for favorite season. I fear that’s what this one will be used as and that discussion while a fair one becomes divisive. IMO a poll for favorite season should come only after a show ends.


Fair viewpoint, I would just like to see if maybe people's favourite episodes are from a particular season but they may enjoy a different season overall. Muckle9999 might be like that, he had 2 Season 1 episodes in his Top 3 but from reading his comments in the past where he posts about his enjoyment of Mon-El (a.k.a. Monty) he might vote in a season only poll for Season 2 as his favourite. Perhaps Muckle could confirm this.

While I'm not much interested in this poll anymore (due to it generating the same results as previously) I am interested in reading what people's Top 3 episodes are so keep those comments coming.


Confirmed! Season 2 is my favorite out of the 4.
I didn't know who Melissa Benoist was until I watched Supergirl. I became an instant fan. So season one was like Christmas with each episode being a present to unwrap and enjoy. Most of the episodes from season 1 through 3 were either good, very good or great.
+1 #20 RE: Best Episode So Far: Prove It!Kiwi 2019-06-10 12:44
Quoting Brierrose:
Quoting Kiwi:
After the best episode poll I would've probably done one for best (or favourite) season (plus 4 results are easier to read than 87 :-) ).
Please no poll for favorite season. I fear that’s what this one will be used as and that discussion while a fair one becomes divisive. IMO a poll for favorite season should come only after a show ends.


Fair viewpoint, I would just like to see if maybe people's favourite episodes are from a particular season but they may enjoy a different season overall. Muckle9999 might be like that, he had 2 Season 1 episodes in his Top 3 but from reading his comments in the past where he posts about his enjoyment of Mon-El (a.k.a. Monty) he might vote in a season only poll for Season 2 as his favourite. Perhaps Muckle could confirm this.

While I'm not much interested in this poll anymore (due to it generating the same results as previously) I am interested in reading what people's Top 3 episodes are so keep those comments coming.
#19 RE: Best Episode So Far: Prove It!LibertyPrime 2019-06-10 12:17
Quoting Brierrose:
Please no poll for favorite season. I fear that’s what this one will be used as and that discussion while a fair one becomes divisive. IMO a poll for favorite season should come only after a show ends.

Any poll or discussion about the best anything has the potential to be divisive. Much of that rests on the spirit with which one views the results.

To me, these polls are a fun exercise, nothing more. I have my own rankings. With all respect to the collective verdict, it won't invalidate them--nor should it invalidate anyone else's. :-)


Register as a user to comment on this article. Register